The right mixer for a 500-seat church looks different from the right mixer for a touring band or a corporate conference setup. Your ideal choice comes down to how you work, what your setup demands, and where you want to invest.
Below, we'll walk through how analog and digital mixers handle audio, what makes each type worth considering, and how to match the right board to your needs.
What Is an Audio Mixer?
An audio mixer is the central hub of any sound system. It takes multiple audio signals, from microphones, instruments, playback devices, and other sources, and combines them into a controlled mix. This mix is then sent to speakers, recording systems, or broadcast feeds.
Every mixer gives the operator control over volume, tone, routing, and effects for each audio input.
The main difference between analog and digital mixers comes down to how they handle that signal and what tools they give you to do it along the way.
How Analog Mixers Work
An analog mixer processes audio as a continuous electrical signal from input to output. The input signal enters the channel, passes through a preamp, then moves through EQ, aux sends, and the channel fader before reaching the master fader and the main outputs. The entire signal path is electrical. There is no conversion to digital at any point in the analog console.
The physical layout of an analog mixer is one of its defining characteristics. Each channel strip has its own dedicated knobs and faders for gain, EQ bands, aux sends, pan, and level. What you see is what you get. A 32-channel analog console has 32 physical channel strips laid out in front of you, giving the operator full tactile control over every parameter in real time.
This straightforward signal flow is a big part of why many audio engineers and sound engineers still prefer analog gear for certain applications.
Pros of Analog Mixers
- Warm, natural sound quality with harmonic character that many professionals prefer for live sound and analog recording
- Intuitive, hands-on workflow. One knob per function means no menu diving
- Simple, predictable signal flow that's easy to learn and troubleshoot
- Zero latency in signal processing
- Generally more affordable at entry-level and mid-range price points
- Highly reliable with fewer points of failure (no software crashes)
Cons of Analog Mixers
- Larger physical footprint, especially at higher channel counts (a 48-channel analog console takes up serious space)
- Limited or no onboard signal processing (you'll need external rack gear for effects, dynamics, and advanced EQ)
- No scene recall or preset storage. Every mix starts from scratch
- Less flexible routing compared to digital equivalents
- Harder to integrate with digital recording without an external audio interface
- Expansion options are limited; adding channels usually means a bigger board
Shop Professional Audio Mixers at AVGear
Browse a wide selection of pro-grade analog and digital mixing consoles from the industry's most trusted brands. All evaluated, tested, and ready to ship.
How Digital Mixers Work
A digital audio mixer converts the incoming analog signal into a digital signal at the input stage. From there, all processing (EQ, dynamics, effects, routing) happens inside the console's DSP (digital signal processing) engine. The processed digital audio is then converted back to an analog signal at the outputs for your speakers, or it can be sent directly to a digital recording system or network.
Digital mixing consoles pack a massive amount of processing power into a compact form factor. A single digital board can handle dozens (sometimes hundreds) of channels with full signal processing on every single channel, all built in.
Most modern digital mixers also feature an expansion slot for audio networking cards (Dante, AVB, MADI), USB or network-based digital recording, remote control via tablets and laptops, and programmable routing that can be reconfigured in seconds.
Pros of Digital Mixers
- Compact size with high channel counts (a digital mixer handling 64 channels can be smaller than a 24-channel analog console)
- Full onboard signal processing on every channel (EQ, dynamics, effects, delay)
- Scene recall and preset storage - save and recall entire show files for different live events and live performances
- Built-in integration with digital recording and digital audio workstations
- Remote mixing capability through Wi-Fi apps and external control surfaces
- Highly flexible signal routing and patching
- Expansion slot options for audio networking (Dante, Waves, MADI)
- Lower stage box weight with digital snakes replacing heavy analog multi-core cables
Cons of Digital Mixers
- Steeper learning curve - navigating layers, menus, and screens takes time to master
- Higher upfront cost for professional-grade digital mixing consoles
- Can feel less immediate without dedicated tactile controls for every parameter
- Dependent on software and firmware updates
- Potential for system crashes, though rare with modern, well-maintained gear
- Troubleshooting digital issues can require more specialized knowledge
Analog vs Digital Mixers: Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Analog Mixer | Digital Mixer |
|---|---|---|
| Sound Character | Warm, natural analog audio | Clean, precise digital audio |
| Signal Path | Fixed, straightforward | Flexible, fully programmable |
| Size & Weight | Larger footprint per channel | Compact for equivalent channel count |
| Built-in Effects | Minimal or none | Extensive onboard processing |
| Scene Recall & Presets | Not available | Full scene recall and show storage |
| Learning Curve | Low — intuitive layout | Moderate to high — menu-based |
| Entry-Level Price | Lower | Higher |
| High-End Price | Comparable | Comparable |
| Recording Integration | Requires external audio interface | Often built-in (USB, Dante, MADI) |
| Dynamic Range | Excellent | Excellent |
| Live Sound Suitability | Great for smaller, simpler setups | Scales well for large productions |
| Expansion & Networking | Limited | Extensive (Dante, AVB, MADI, etc.) |
Which Mixer Is Best for Live Sound?
There's no single right answer here. The best mixer for live sound depends entirely on your setup, your budget, and how you prefer to work. Here's a practical breakdown.
Choose an Analog Mixer If…
- You prefer hands-on, real-time mixing with a dedicated knob or fader for every function
- Your channel count is manageable (16–32 channels covers most of your gigs)
- You want a simpler, more straightforward mix workflow with minimal setup time
- Budget is a primary concern and you need a capable board without a large investment
- You value the warmth and character of analog audio in your signal chain
- Your setup doesn't require scene recall or complex routing
- Reliability and simplicity are top priorities for your audio system
Choose a Digital Mixer If…
- You need high channel counts in a compact, portable form factor
- You run multiple live events with different configurations and need scene recall
- You want built-in effects and signal processing without filling a rack with outboard gear
- You need tight integration with digital recording, streaming, or broadcast
- You mix monitors and front-of-house from a single digital board
- Remote mixing capability (iPad/tablet control) is important to your workflow
- You need advanced routing flexibility and audio networking through a digital device
Popular Mixer Brands to Know
The pro audio world has no shortage of reputable mixer manufacturers. For analog, brands like Yamaha, Allen & Heath, Soundcraft, Mackie, and Midas have long track records in live sound. On the digital side, DiGiCo, Avid, Yamaha, Allen & Heath, Behringer, PreSonus, and Solid State Logic (SSL) are among the most widely used on stages and in recording studios worldwide.
No matter which direction you lean, buying from a trusted source matters, especially when purchasing used or pre-owned gear. AVGear carries professional mixing consoles from many of these top brands, and every piece of gear goes through a thorough evaluation process before it reaches a buyer.
Analog, Digital, or Both? The Hybrid Approach
It's worth noting that analog vs digital doesn't have to be an either/or decision. Some audio engineers use a hybrid approach, pairing an analog console for its tactile control and sonic character with digital recording, signal processing, or stage boxes. This is common in recording studio environments and is becoming more popular in live sound setups where engineers want the best of both.
For example, an engineer might run an analog front-of-house console but use a digital snake and Dante networking for stage connections, or pair analog summing with a digital audio workstation for live recordings and audio capture.
Find the Right Mixer for Your Setup at AVGear
If you're building out a new rig or upgrading an existing setup, AVGear carries a wide selection of professional audio mixers, both analog and digital mixing consoles from the industry's most trusted brands. Looking for a deal? Check out AVGear's live auctions for a chance to bid on pro-grade gear at competitive prices.
Looking to upgrade? AVGear also makes it easy to sell your used audio, lighting, and production gear through a full-service, hassle-free disposition process. Our team handles everything from evaluation to remarketing, so you can put the value of your retired equipment toward your next investment.
AVGear has been a trusted name in the pro AV secondary market since 2014, serving production companies, rental houses, houses of worship, venues, and organizations of all sizes across the globe. Whether you're buying, selling, or trading, AVGear is built to help you get the most out of your professional audio and production equipment.
Buy, Sell, Trade, or Bid on Pro Audio Mixers
Looking to buy, sell, trade, or bid on professional audio mixers? AVGear connects you with top-brand analog and digital consoles through direct sales, live auctions, and full-service trade-in and disposition programs.